David De Gea sucks

De Gea for Spain is not the same as De Gea for Man United

it's like with Ter Stegen, or Sané

doesn't mean he sucks, obviously, he's a top keeper. He's just struggling with concentration playing for a team with all that possession. At Man Utd he's busy all the time stopping poverty shots, and he's not used to his team controlling the game.

Firenze wrote:

breva wrote:I never thought he was exceptional. We have plenty of goalkeepers in Serie A that are as good or better.

You must have been hitting the Amaretto pretty hard tonight to spout such nonsense. (understandable when you see the World Cup underway without Italy)

As good or better.

Buffon
Donnaruma
Perin
Handanovic
Reina
Szczęsny
Strakosha
Alisson

Another long day at the pub i suppose ? I also used to rate Serie A keepers but this list cannot challenge David De Gea who's been great since 5 years or more

Buffon leaves for another league
Donnarumma too young and had a shit season
Perin not proven enough
Handanovic best days behind him
Reina let's just pass
Szczesny 1½ good season in his career
Strakosha is only agility... spectacular but mistake prone, poor positioning
Alisson not proven enough

Most of them can find a good job in Premier League yet DDG remains above by a large margin

breva wrote:

Firenze wrote:

breva wrote:I never thought he was exceptional. We have plenty of goalkeepers in Serie A that are as good or better.

You must have been hitting the Amaretto pretty hard tonight to spout such nonsense. (understandable when you see the World Cup underway without Italy)

As good or better.

Buffon
Donnaruma
Perin
Handanovic
Reina Seriously
Szczęsny
Strakosha
Alisson

breva wrote:

Firenze wrote:

breva wrote:I never thought he was exceptional.  We have plenty of goalkeepers in Serie A that are as good or better.

You must have been hitting the Amaretto pretty hard tonight to spout such nonsense. (understandable when you see the World Cup underway without Italy)

As good or better.

Buffon
Donnaruma
Perin
Handanovic
Reina
Szczęsny
Strakosha
Alisson

Then again, same dude that said Lazio is better than Atletico Madrid.

breva wrote:

Firenze wrote:

breva wrote:I never thought he was exceptional. We have plenty of goalkeepers in Serie A that are as good or better.

You must have been hitting the Amaretto pretty hard tonight to spout such nonsense. (understandable when you see the World Cup underway without Italy)

As good or better.

Buffon
Donnaruma
Perin
Handanovic
Reina
Szczęsny
Strakosha
Alisson

Lmao

Just Alisson can be better atm (for me Buffon is done ) because he was so impressive this year, but we can compare him just with Serie A level ( I've always said he is best Serie A GK, not best GK in the world tbh. i expect he will be the new thing in that role though)

The rest not only is worse , but it's hard even to define them as good.
Strakosha is the hero that gave us CL place on last matchday,isn't him ?
Donnarumma (worst Serie  A GK with Sportiello this year ? ) Perin ( Who ?. ) Reina Handanovic lmao . Asking to an Inter fan if he 'd not swap those 2

That list is Aids.

breva wrote:

Firenze wrote:

breva wrote:I never thought he was exceptional. We have plenty of goalkeepers in Serie A that are as good or better.

You must have been hitting the Amaretto pretty hard tonight to spout such nonsense. (understandable when you see the World Cup underway without Italy)

As good or better.

Buffon
Donnaruma
Perin
Handanovic
Reina
Szczęsny
Strakosha
Alisson

Superb list, Upventused

Hapless_Hans wrote:De Gea for Spain is not the same as De Gea for Man United

it's like with Ter Stegen, or Sané

doesn't mean he sucks, obviously, he's a top keeper. He's just struggling with concentration playing for a team with all that possession. At Man Utd he's busy all the time stopping poverty shots, and he's not used to his team controlling the game.

In a team of shit players, if you are less shittier than your teammates, it makes you look better than you actually are.

Wow can’t believe this thread. It’s like you have never seen him play except for this one abnormal error. Yes it was a big error but other than that he has been great both for Spain and club.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IBSxy2dsgJU

Mr Nick09 wrote:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IBSxy2dsgJU

That fly swat, back-handed skill move near the end was 9/10, though. A less experienced goalie wouldn't have even attempted it.

this guy is so overrated, lmao

straight garbage

best GK in the world by far

why you heff to be med

it's fine you are signing alisson or ludnin or strakoshitea or someone

be happy

awful with his feet and not a great shot stopper either

another overhyped Premier Leauge player

[quote="Myesyats"not a great shot stopper [/quote]

La Liga fanboy agendas ffs, Myesats still mad at me shitting on that German benchwarmer earlier in the season

He hasn't been great this WC, so I'll allow it for now. GOAT league watchers know the reality.

If he isn't a good shot stopper nobody is lmao, enough of your England fan on Ibra level of evaluations.

alright ter Stegen is awful with Germany aswell so i'll allow De Gea to suck in the WC

But still I think ter Stegen is better overall, he at least won a CL and played a huge part in it de gea stopping shots against Crystal Balance isn't comparable imo

That's not De Gea's fault though, Man Yoo have been a very shit team ( compared to the standards you are comparing to be) who have only been as good as they are because of him.

Only ones to blame for that is Man Utd's board and the manager.

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:That's not De Gea's fault though, Man Yoo have been a very shit team ( compared to the standards you are comparing to be) who have only been as good as they are because of him.

Only ones to blame for that is Man Utd's board and the manager.

And De Gea's garlicky butter fingers

+1 for garlic butter

This dude is absolute rubbish

Lost count of the amount of times this guy just stands rooted to the ground from a shot/header

Mr Nick09 wrote:

Great Leader Sprucenuce wrote:That's not De Gea's fault though, Man Yoo have been a very shit team ( compared to the standards you are comparing to be) who have only been as good as they are because of him.

Only ones to blame for that is Man Utd's board and the manager.

And De Gea's garlicky butter fingers

+1 for garlic butter

looool

I really do not get how De Gea can be so good for Utd (he really is) but boils down to Donnarumma level of silliness for Spain.

http://www2.squawka.com/comparison-matrix#la_liga/2017/2018/marc-andr%C3%A9_ter_stegen/862/862/2088/0/p|premier_league/2017/2018/david_de_gea/819/819/590/0/p#clean_sheets/goals_conceded/saves/saves_per_goal/distribution_accuracy/avg_distribution_length/punches/catches/successful_passes/pass_completion/total_passes/total_score/defence_score#total