what is your opinion on Managers quiting jobs because of fatigue

I heard Guidolin wanted to leave Udinese , Pep guardiola did and there are more are adding to the list

while Managers Like Wenger or SaF are not feeling tired

My opinion is, they should quit, and not be ridiculed for it, if they don't feel up to it. Being a football manager makes you an instant celebrity, the press can be vicious, and you usually get little support from your own people who will fire your ass the second you lose an important match, no matter whether it was your fault or not.

IMHO serious afflictions like burn-out or depression don't get the respect and thoughtful treatment they deserve often enough, so if a manager feels like he needs a break, he should take it. Same goes for any other human being as well.

Enke wasn't too long ago...

At least Wenger and Fergie have had success over the years. Imagine how Moyes must feel

I had forgotten about Enke

Indeed , it seems only right that if any coach feels like that , they have every right to do so. Health in general comes first , nothing's worth it without health.

Can't really be compared to be honest, you never know what is going on with their personal life, with family, or health.
For example, there have been many managers before who have called for a break because they have been depressed due to the amount of stress etc you never know.

Exactly, I mean I get why people are taking digs at Guardiola, he pretty much had only success, got treated rather well by the international press, and didn't seem like he was close to having burnout, but you never know whether he just has very good self-control.

Just last season Ralf Rangnick quit Schalke because of burnout, and I rather have a guy like that take a break, then totally collapse.

agree with OP 100%. Football is a vicious and cruel sport - on and off the pitch.

Managing Real and Barca are the two toughest and most demanding jobs in football, bar none.

Let alone in Pep's situation, he was a Barcelona player, and after retiring the player status, worked for the team I do think he should get a break much deserved.

VivaStPauli wrote:Just last season Ralf Rangnick quit Schalke because of burnout, and I rather have a guy like that take a break, then totally collapse.

THAN totally collapse, THAN, BIG difference, sorry. :X

Lex wrote:At least Wenger and Fergie have had success over the years. Imagine how Moyes must feel

Good call on Moyes , he is just a great manager or i just like his accent ,lol

VivaStPauli wrote:My opinion is, they should quit, and not be ridiculed for it, if they don't feel up to it. Being a football manager makes you an instant celebrity, the press can be vicious, and you usually get little support from your own people who will fire your ass the second you lose an important match, no matter whether it was your fault or not.

IMHO serious afflictions like burn-out or depression don't get the respect and thoughtful treatment they deserve often enough, so if a manager feels like he needs a break, he should take it. Same goes for any other human being as well.

Enke wasn't too long ago...

100% signed. The Rangnick comment (with "than"), too.