Is Marchisio better than any CM in the EPL?

Is he?

Marchisio? Really?

At what? What a very generic question...

Do you rate him higher overall than any other Central Midfielder in the EPL? Because I do.

As long as we're not comparing him to the CAMs then yes I do.

Then again his form has been meh for a couple of months.

What kind of question is this?

Is he better than any midfielder? Yeah, hes better than Anderson..now what?

Are you trying to ask, is there a better PL midfielder than him? Or im missing something?

Yaya is better hands down.

Better at what exactly?

yeah he prob is tbh, he is better than yaya imo, yaya is very overrated.

Overall? Yaya Toure and Carrick.

Although they don't play the same role, i think Carrick is better at what he does than Marchisio.. He is more consistent, Marchisio had to many ups and downs, he was good in UCL (bar bayern games) but no where near as consistent as Carrick in the league, so the answer to the topic's question is no..

No, no he is not.

This thread is even funnier than the Henry/Drogba thread

Ion Creanga wrote:Although they don't play the same role, i think Carrick is better at what he does than Marchisio.. He is more consistent, Marchisio had to many ups and downs, he was good in UCL (bar bayern games) but no where near as consistent as Carrick in the league, so the answer to the topic's question is no..

Wise man . However, Marchisio is one of the best midfielders from Serie A and he could also be one of the best in EPL. He can run for days, he can defend very well, he can make the difference in attack and his dedication for his club can't be described in words.

Consistency is what he lacks at the moment. I watched almost all Juve's games in the last two seasons and in comparison with Vidal, Marchisio can easily disappear from the game and 'stay hidden' until the final whistle.