Best Ever Goalkeeper based on Ballon d'Or and FWPOTY

Win based on highest ranked goal keeper on Ballon d'Or 56-90, Ballon d'Or and FWPOTY with the current voting method 91-09, Fifa Ballon d'Or 10~.

Most Wins

9
Lev Yashin

5
Iker Casillas

4
Gianluigi Buffon
Peter Schmeichel
Rinat Dassayev
Ronnie Hellström

3
Dino Zoff

2
Manuel Neuer
Oliver Kahn
Fabien Barthez
Jean-Marie Pfaff
Ivo Viktor
Gordon Banks

Wins

1956 Yashin
1957 Yashin
1958 Gregg
1959 Yashin
1960 Yashin
1961 Yashin
1962 Schroiff
1963 Yashin
1964 Yashin
1965 Yashin
1966 Yashin
1967 -
1968 -
1969 Viktor
1970 Banks
1971 Rudakov
1972 Banks
1973 Zoff
1974 Hellström/Tomaszewski
1975 Maier
1976 Viktor
1977 Hellström
1978 Hellström
1979 Hellström
1980 Zoff/Arconada
1981 Zoff
1982 Dassaev
1983 Dassaev/Pfaff
1984 Schumacher
1985 Dassaev
1986 Ducadam
1987 Pfaff
1988 Dassaev
1989 Shilton
1990 Zenga

1991 Martini
1992 Schmeichel
1993 Schemichel
1994 Ravelli
1995 Baia
1996 Chilavert
1997 Schmeichel
1998 Barthez
1999 Schmeichel
2000 Barthez
2001 Kahn
2002 Kahn
2003 Buffon
2004 Buffon
2005 Chech
2006 Buffon
2007 Buffon
2008 Casillas
2009 Casillas

2010 Casillas
2011 Casillas
2012 Casillas
2013 Neuer
2014 Neuer

Saint Iker.

Obviously we all know the purpose of this thread is:

Casillas = 2nd best goalkeeper of all time.

Messi = bucketloads of goals vs. Casillas.

=> Messi = GOAT.

But before it turns to that, let me just say again: Saint Iker.

Neuer will dominate the next 10 years on that

Lev Yashin

futbol wrote:Obviously we all know the purpose of this thread is:

Casillas = 2nd best goalkeeper of all time.

Messi = bucketloads of goals vs. Casillas.

=> Messi = GOAT.

But before it turns to that, let me just say again: Saint Iker.

Now that you mention it.

This is all leading up to Harmonica being slang for Edward Nygma imo.

Buffon has a chance to catch Casillas this year if he beats Neuer.

Could be also done for defenders and midfielders this.

Buffon in his prime is the best GK I have ever seen. The man was a monster. I thought Cech before he got that head injury would reach that level. Shame. Iker was never better than Buffon. Iker at his peak never even approached the GOATs level. Neuer reminds me of Big Pete. Both have/had a howler in them

It's so sad that Lev Yashin was far before the time of most people here. I would really have loved to see him in action

I came in here half expecting Messi to be the best GK of all time.

Seriously disappointing Harmonica.

Well technically he's going to match Yashin this season as he hasn't lost to a goalie since 2006.

Spoiler:

Harmonica wrote:Well technically he's going to match Yashin this season as he hasn't lost to a goalie since 2006.

Spoiler:

Interesting , it's a shame Zenga is often reminded for that mistake against Caniggia in Italy-Argentina '90 (exactly 90 ) , he was a GOAT GK

anyway , I don't deny Casillas was a great GK but I have many doubts about this supermacy 5 in a row

But Martini ( ? ) best GK in 91 ?