Muntari's Goal was offside

Muntari's Goal is originally offside since Vidal was completely off the pitch
check the below image:

Sorry man.. it doesn't mean anything he was off the pitch. It wasn't offside and a perfectly legit goal.

dronte wrote:Sorry man.. it doesn't mean anything he was off the pitch. It wasn't offside and a perfectly legit goal.

I think if a player is outside the pitch he isnt considered as the last defender.. if am not mistaken

ali_a_dbouk wrote:

dronte wrote:Sorry man.. it doesn't mean anything he was off the pitch. It wasn't offside and a perfectly legit goal.

I think if a player is outside the pitch he isnt considered as the last defender.. if am not mistaken

Yes he is. I remember, I guess it was the WC when a player was treated outside the line and he was counted in as an active defender (lol), it made so much controversy. Hopefully someone can give me a link on that coz sadly I can't remember which match it was.

dronte wrote:

ali_a_dbouk wrote:

dronte wrote:Sorry man.. it doesn't mean anything he was off the pitch. It wasn't offside and a perfectly legit goal.

I think if a player is outside the pitch he isnt considered as the last defender.. if am not mistaken

Yes he is. I remember, I guess it was the WC when a player was treated outside the line and he was counted in as an active defender (lol), it made so much controversy. Hopefully someone can give me a link on that coz sadly I can't remember which match it was.

I remember at the euros 2008 there was a match involving holland where something like that happened

dronte wrote:coz sadly I can't remember which match it was.

Italy - Netherland on Nistelrooy's goal

Seth wrote:

dronte wrote:coz sadly I can't remember which match it was.

Italy - Netherland on Nistelrooy's goal

Thanks mate.

Anyways back on topic, it would be stupid if you could just leave the pitch to make someone offside.

So the goal was offsides?

juveman17 wrote:So the goal was offsides?

Nope, I really don't think it was.

Yes it was off look at van nistelrooys goal they didnt count it

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhDFtkCb2vY

I can't remember, why was Vidal off the pitch? Did he just wonder off or was he injured and waiting to come back on? If its the latter then it should be offside.

But either way im happy with a draw vs Milan at the San siro!

#stillunbeaten!

I think he did it on purpose but it doesent matter cuz thts not how the rule goes if he not in play than its off

Offside

Still cant believe what im reading, you guys are fkn hilarious

Cassius_Case wrote:I can't remember, why was Vidal off the pitch? Did he just wonder off or was he injured and waiting to come back on? If its the latter then it should be offside.

But either way im happy with a draw vs Milan at the San siro!

#stillunbeaten!

CroInter wrote:Still cant believe what im reading, you guys are fkn hilarious

What's wrong with that? Do you not agree with that?

yeah, we're hilarious 24/7th.

I would be angry too if my club could not win a game to save their lives.



Inter milan are a joke

Inter milan
Juve

juveman17 wrote:I think he did it on purpose but it doesent matter cuz thts not how the rule goes if he not in play than its off

Seriously. Show me that rule which says if someone is off the pitch than he isn't considered as an active player. It doesn't make sense at all.
If he received treatment and couldn't enter the pitch, it could base an argument, but simply wandering off doesn't mean he is not active..

CroInter wrote:Still cant believe what im reading, you guys are fkn hilarious

Seriously, how come you still dare to come here trolling? Your team is damn hilarious now, and every post you make is just full of sh*t.

dronte wrote:

juveman17 wrote:I think he did it on purpose but it doesent matter cuz thts not how the rule goes if he not in play than its off

Seriously. Show me that rule which says if someone is off the pitch than he isn't considered as an active player. It doesn't make sense at all.
If he received treatment and couldn't enter the pitch, it could base an argument, but simply wandering off doesn't mean he is not active..

CroInter wrote:Still cant believe what im reading, you guys are fkn hilarious

Seriously, how come you still dare to come here trolling? Your team is damn hilarious now, and every post you make is just full of sh*t.

Inter hilarious? Yeah i know dude, right?

Trolling? Nop, i find this thread and amount of knowledge in here beyond hilarious.

On topic, Muntari is clearly offside, as proven experts @Juvesection

Being outside of the pitch does nothing as he still counts in the game. There was no offside and Vidal was really foolish in not knowing the rules.

No doubt it should have counted. 100%

guys the ref *bleep* the game up

He disallowed regular goal for Muntari, when I was taking exam for ref they told me that the worst thing a ref could do is to compensate about one mistake and than he disallowed Matri's goal, than he tried to 'regain control' of the match giving away tons of yellow cards. Like that wasn't enough Mexes punched borriello and Muntari done the same to Chiellini than Vidal tried to break some legs.

all in all this is disgrace for Italian football