Greatest Players of All Time for each team

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Galatasaray - either Gheorghe Hagi or Metin Oktay?

Kaladin wrote:
Manchester United - Raiola/Mendes

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Glasgow Rangers - Ally McCoist

Celtic - either Billy McNeill or Jimmy McGrory?

Leeds United - Billy Bremner

River Plate - either Enzo Francescoli or Daniel Passarella or Angel Labruna?

FC Porto - either Mario Jardel or Paulo Futre or Ljuinko Drulovic or Deco or Fernando Gomes or Rabah Madjer?

guest_07 wrote:Glasgow Rangers - Ally McCoist

Wasn't he a commentator on like...FIFA 2005?

John Motson and Ally McCoist

My fav FIFA game

15 years ago...fuck I feel old

guest_07 wrote:Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Galatasaray - either Gheorghe Hagi or Metin Oktay?

One salam a day is enough akhi

RealGunner wrote:

guest_07 wrote:Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Galatasaray - either Gheorghe Hagi or Metin Oktay?

One salam a day is enough akhi

Hadith says,
"Whoever meets his brother,
he should greet his brother,
so that if the two are separated by a tree or a wall
then the two meet again
then he should greet him."

My religion encourage Muslim
to always greet (salam)
which mean
keep wishing good to others.

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Benfica - Eusebio

Sporting CP (Sporting Lisbon) - Fernando Peyroteo

Borussia Mönchengladbach - Jupp Heynckes / Günter Netzer / Berti Vogts ?

Fiorentina - Gabriel Batistuta / Giancarlo Antognoni / Julinho ?

Parma - Hernán Crespo / Gianfranco Zola / Faustino Asprilla ?

Tottenham Hotspur - Jimmy Greaves / Glenn Hoddle / Dave Mackay ?

Sampdoria - Roberto Mancini

Independiente - Ricardo Bochini

Estudientes - Juan Ramón Verón

San Lorenzo - José Sanfilippo

Vélez Sarsfield - Jose Chilavert / Carlos Bianchi ?

Hamburg - Felix Magath / Uwe Seeler ?

Schalke 04 - Fritz Szepan / Ernst Kuzorra ?

Werder Bremen - Claudio Pizarro / Marco Bode ?

Kaiserslautern - Klaus Toppmöller

Bayer Leverkusen - Ulf Kirsten

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Stuttgart - Karl Allgöwer

Atletico Madrid - Luis Aragones

guest_07 wrote:
Liverpool - either Kenny Daglish or Steven Gerrard or John Barnes or Kevin Keegan?

danyjr wrote:
England
Liverpool: Torres/Gerrard

M99 wrote:
Liverpool - Dalglish/Rush

Robespierre wrote:
Liverpool - Dalglish

Kaladin wrote:
Liverpool - Dalglish/Gerrard

Kevin Keegan and John Barnes are not particularly close in the discussion of Liverpool GOAT. It's only between two players. Torres is laughable. Ian Rush is run away 3rd but not close to the legend status of Dalglish/Gerrard.

1a. Dalglish
1b. Gerrard
3. Ian Rush

And then the rest below that. I'd personally put Barnes at 4 because we won 2 League Titles with him as our best player and played some of the best football in club history during 88-90 and he was our captain for a while as well as being with us for a long time.

Keegan wasn't with us long enough (only 6 seasons) as well as forcing a move away during his prime that would be the only hits against his claim in the Liverpool GOAT rankings. Otherwise he would easily round off top 4, but Barnes gets ahead of him for that reason. I don't think Keegan even gets in the top 5. I'd have to really think about who the 5th place would be. Fowler, Hansen, Souness, Emlyn Hughes etc all have genuine shouts here alongside Keegan for that 5th spot.

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Sevilla - Jesus Navas / Frederic Kanoute ?

Athletic Bilbao - Telmo Zarra

PSG - Zlatan

PSG was something far different before the qatari investment, i used to like the aura of this club as i began following football. But now they are contenders in CL, they can be considered a top tier club (like it or not) and to me this makes the last decade the most valuable in their history, so i place the Rais and Pauletas lower by default

And it's Zlatan who gave credibility to this project, not Pastore or Thiago Motta then losing the league to Montpelier. Nor is it Neymar, Mbappé who come as the club is mocked for flopping in CL (...)
Talent wise Zlatan is better than any of those guys anyway


About other clubs, same as other posters said more or less, nothing to add

In fact i have something to add

Sassuolo - Berardi

Warrior wrote:PSG - Zlatan

PSG was something far different before the qatari investment, i used to like the aura of this club as i began following football. But now they are contenders in CL, they can be considered a top tier club (like it or not) and to me this makes the last decade the most valuable in their history, so i place the Rais and Pauletas lower by default

And it's Zlatan who gave credibility to this project, not Pastore or Thiago Motta then losing the league to Montpelier. Nor is it Neymar, Mbappé who come as the club is mocked for flopping in CL (...)
Talent wise Zlatan is better than any of those guys anyway


About other clubs, same as other posters said more or less, nothing to add

Not to be forgotten,
Safet Susic was voted
Paris Saint-Germain's best player of all time
and the best foreign player of Ligue 1 of all time
by France Football in 2010.

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Red Stars Belgrade - Dragan Dzajic

Steaua Bucharest - Anghel Iordănescu

Salam to brother @guest_07 and to everyone else

IMO if the two should be separated by a tree, they could just take a step forward past the tree. Or a couple of steps if we are talking about a mammoth tree.
If I were to go hiking in a forest with a friend, I wouldn't need them to say "Good day, peace be with you" to me every time we go past a tree.
So I don't necessarily think the prophet has a point here.

The wall argument makes sense though, assuming there's no door.

In my local club the greatest player is Ignacio Piatti... i wonder do argentinian posters even know about him lol

I know a Pablo Piatti

Pablo Piatti plays for the biggest rival Toronto, he was in Liga for more than a decade before that

Ignacio (Nacho) played most of his career in Argentina league, some flops in Europe too, but he became a beast in MLS in his early 30s

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Sao Paulo - Rogerio Ceni

Botafogo - Garrincha

Vasco Da Gama - Roberto Dinamite

Internacional - Paulo Roberto Falcão

Cruzeiro - Tostão

Lyon - Juninho Pernambucano

Bordeaux - Alain Giresse

Nantes - Bernard Blanchet / Vahid Halilhodzic ?

Assalamu'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh to Muslim
& Good day to the rest

Fenerbahçe - Alex / Lefter Küçükandonyadis ?

Cagliari - Gigi Riva
Pro Vercelli - Silvio Piola
Livorno - Lucarelli
Torino - Valentino Mazzola
Udinese - Di Natale

Udinese had also Zico tbf

it's true that it's not enough to be the best player on paper   the election of the GOAT  ( I mean, Riquelme is the GOAT for Boca even though they had Maradona too) because we must consider different aspects .. and so yes, apparently Di Natale is the perfect proper name ... but Zico is something of too much big for a club as Udinese. Zico at Udinese. It sound so weird to me think it . Probably the most ' randomic' transfer ever for Serie A

I wonder what an Udinese fan 'd say . But probably Di Natale wins equally

@danyjr Bergomi one of our best players yes , but for me your compatriot Javier Zanetti > Giuseppe Bergomi

Botafogo : Garrincha @elitedam

Robespierre wrote:Udinese had also Zico tbf

it's true that it's  not enough to be the best player on paper   the election of the GOAT  ( I mean, Riquelme is the GOAT for Boca even though they had Maradona too) because we must consider different aspects .. and so yes, apparently Di Natale is the perfect proper name ... but Zico is something of too much big for a club as Udinese. Zico at Udinese. It sound so weird to me think it . Probably the most ' randomic' transfer ever for Serie A

I wonder what an Udinese fan 'd say . But probably Di Natale wins equally

Below is the statement that
support your bolded statement.

https://www.goal.com/en-us/news/3297/argentina/2010/11/15/2215236/boca-juniors-ideal-xi-the-best-of-the-bosteros

Juan Roman Riquelme, number 10 (1995-02, 2007-):

Only in Boca,
and only for this remarkable playmaker,
could Diego Maradona be relegated to second fiddle.

In the Bombonera however it is Roman who rules the roost over the best player ever to step on a football pitch. Blessed with incredible control and vision and a right foot that seems trained to find a teammate no matter how unlikely the pass,
Riquelme was voted the greatest player of Boca’s history in a recent poll.