Rate our summer signings

There is a thread in GS but I know a lot of Milanisti don't post much there so here is our very own thread. Rate our signings from A to F.

---

Andrea Poli

Had an excellent start to his Milan career where he was our best player in the first month of the season. A great pick for just 6 million. However, he has not been able to match his early season form in latter parts of the season owing to injury and mismanagement by Allegri who favoured Muntari over him for defensive grit and steel. He also adequately covered for RB position when all our fullbacks were injured and was still one of our better midfielders for the entire season. Age is on his side too.

Grade B

Kaka

Kaka arrived for free on deadline day and instantly got injured for a month. He became Milan's best player after his return from injury and gave inspired performances in both Champions League and Serie A. Some poor games (eg: Inter) stop him from getting an A.

Grade B

Jherson Vergara

N/A

Alessandro Matri

Was always against this transfer as our forward line was the last place we needed reinforcements on. This pos has given absolutely shocking performances. Missing sitters, misplacing passes, mistiming runs, absolute waste of 12 million who will hopefully be scrubbing toilets at Milanello now that Pazzini is back. Misses out on an F because of one sole goal against Parma.

Grade E

Cristian Zapata

No comments. Contemplated suicide because of this man. Misses out on lower than F because he got 3 goals this season and had a good tackle on the Roma game.

Grade F

Matias Silvestre

Has given ok performances when he played. Has been far better than Zapata and his Inter self and there was no fee involved in getting him. Deserves more game time over that Colombian abomination.

Grade C

Valter Birsa

Gave two match winning performances at the CAM role but has been quiet since. His performance level has dropped at the wing and playing beside Kaka. Once again, no fee involved in getting him.

Grade C

I agree with you on most of these.

Poli: Inconsistent but our best midfielder behind de Jong. B
Kaka: Also inconsistent but he's had some great matches and is often our best/only attacking threat. B
Matri: Absolute trash. F
Zapata: Probably our worst defender. D
Silvestre: Haven't seen him play enough.
Birsa: Had a couple good games but faded when Kaka came back from injury. C