Re: Aguero vs Suarez

by FennecFox7 Tue Aug 16, 2011 3:00 pm

Suarez is better..

by Albiceleste Tue Aug 16, 2011 3:40 pm

Aguero is better and more talented, he has amazing technique, finishing, strength he's a little bull, the guy is ridiculously gifted and if put in the right team can be a balon d'or contender.

by zarola Tue Aug 16, 2011 3:42 pm

Pazzo debut >>>>> Aguero debut

by Arquitecto Tue Aug 16, 2011 10:21 pm

St_Nick09_of_Goal wrote:
Arquitecto wrote:

I'm guessing you haven't seen the difference between the La Liga and Eredivisie defenses have you? Its quite funny how people underrate the dutch league due to its coefficients but haven't seen how strong they really are in Europe against teams in the higher rank.

La Liga defenses are absolutely atrocious btw.

you are always exaggerating when talking about defenses in la liga. You sound as if every quality scorer in la liga drops 30+ goals for fun.

Fact is, the eredivise is not of the same quality level as la liga, no matter how you rate la liga defenses, the eredivise isnt of the same standard.

Aguero never broke the 20 goals mark in la liga, does that mean that if he achieve the same in england, la liga defenses are better than the epl's? fun fact, torres waited to leave la liga to break that ceiling.

In a league where playing and letting play is the philosophy, he scored an awful little amount of goals per season.

I exaggerate due to the fact that defense does not seem to be a priority in the La Liga as all to many times, I have seen little priority over closing down space, tactically working as a unit and overall any other form of defensive astuteness. This is undeniable its common to know that defense is a small priority as attack is clearly favored to the point of neglect.

Yes, the Liga is in a higher level of football but the difference between the leagues is exaggerated.

And torres scoring little in Athletico? He scored 20 goals twice with Athletico.

by Nishankly Tue Aug 16, 2011 10:46 pm

Suarez cuz im biased.

But i really think Suarez is a more complete player than Aguero.

Suarez = cross, pass, shoot,create , finish, dribble, hold, free kicks, Penalties, COPA AMERICA.

Aguero = pass, shoot, create , finish, dribble, hold.

Hahah .. One of the greatest comparisons ever.

by Zees Wed Aug 17, 2011 3:20 am

King Aguero

by Gil Wed Aug 17, 2011 3:32 am

Surprised so many people think Aguero is better. There honestly isn't much between the two of them IMO.

Aguero is probably the better goalscorer but Suarez is a more complete player. There both diving cunts as well.

by Mr Nick09 Wed Aug 17, 2011 3:34 am

Gil wrote:Surprised so many people think Aguero is better. There honestly isn't much between the two of them IMO.

Aguero is probably the better goalscorer but Suarez is a more complete player. There both diving cunts as well.

that's what you get for making a poll the day aguero scores 2 goals and make an assist in 30mn in his debut.

by Red Alert Wed Aug 17, 2011 4:43 pm

Hard one imo... I'll call it a draw. I wonder what Forlan would say though. Razz

by ExtremistEnigma Tue Sep 24, 2013 2:34 am

Was thinking about this.

So many folks with Aguero replies. Laughing

Who is better atm? Who would you rather have in your side?

by Winter is Coming Tue Sep 24, 2013 2:45 am

Aguero has a lot of potential, but to me he hasn't lived up to it exactly yet, but Suarez is a killer right now.

by Vlad the Impaler Tue Sep 24, 2013 2:56 am

Arquitescu wrote:
lszanto wrote:
Arquitecto wrote:LMAO at Aguero being better?

Is it because of his Man City debut?

Fun fact:

Aguero: 291 apps, 126 goals

Suarez: 243 apps, 143 goals.

Question on who is effective on the pitch? Suarez is simply a more complete player then Aguero and plays as SS compared to Kun who plays an inside forward.

Hilarious.
Fun fact: most of suarez's goals came playing in the best team in a lower league... most golden boot counts etc will only count goals in netherlands as 0.5(from memory).
I'm guessing you haven't seen the difference between the La Liga and Eredivisie defenses have you? Its quite funny how people underrate the dutch league due to its coefficients but haven't seen how strong they really are in Europe against teams in the higher rank.

La Liga defenses are absolutely atrocious btw.

Holy shit. I can't believe Arq wrote this. Laughing

La Liga defenses are suffering, but they are still better than those from Eredivisie.

Overrated league honestly; Milan having problem in the first leg against PSV made whole Goal Legacy say that PSV is a strong team and Eredivisie is a fabulous league. But this happens on Goal Legacy everytime. Unfortunately, users change their opinions so many times, like the wind changes its direction.

by RealGunner Tue Sep 24, 2013 5:45 am

Both are one of my favourite players in the league. Suarez is more creative, better dribbler, better link up and more trickier. Aguero is a better finisher, poacher, has better instinct and rest is equal to Suarez.

I'd pick Suarez.

by Mr Nick09 Tue Sep 24, 2013 6:01 am

RealGunner wrote:Both are one of my favourite players in the league. Suarez is more creative, better dribbler, better link up and more trickier. Aguero is a better finisher, poacher, has better instinct and rest is equal to Suarez.

I'd pick Suarez.

the little boy in RVP is suffering

by urbaNRoots Tue Sep 24, 2013 7:43 am

If I had to pick one, Agüero easily. Fantastic all arounder and completes a full season unless he's injured unlike Suárez.

by Albiceleste Tue Sep 24, 2013 12:24 pm

Gil wrote:Surprised so many people think Aguero is better. There honestly isn't much between the two of them IMO.

Aguero is probably the better goalscorer but Suarez is a more complete player. There both diving *bleep* as well.

comparing Suarez's theatrics to the occasional light fall Laughing

gil mah boy Proud

by jibers Thu May 29, 2014 11:31 am

Are people's opinions still the same? Who is the better finisher?

by futbol Thu May 29, 2014 11:40 am

They are both overrated as hell.

by Robespierre Thu May 29, 2014 11:40 am

Aguero is great but Suarez is definitely better. Suarez is simply Suarez .

by jibers Thu May 29, 2014 11:51 am

Fußball wrote:They are both overrated as hell.

Elaborate...

Robespierre wrote:Aguero is great but Suarez is definitely better. Suarez is simply Suarez .

Why? Explain. I think Kun is a better finisher

by futbol Thu May 29, 2014 12:45 pm

jibers wrote:
Fußball wrote:They are both overrated as hell.

Elaborate...

Too lazy. But consider this. Agüero is injured more than every 2nd game. Out of the possible 3420 minutes he has played 1526 in the EPL which is less than 50 %. If you also include the minutes where he actually plays but has to find his rythm you've got a full strength Agüero in about about 30 % of the season. He has missed 2 games against Bayern in the CL and had ONE touch against Barcelona in Camp Nou after missing the game in the Etihad. Not reliable.

Consider also this. Despite him missing more than half of the season City have waltzed the league with 100+ goals regardless.

He scores goals in a heavily adventurous side that produces blow-outs every week against teams that City are expected to beat anyway. Any iconic performance against any reasonable side? Meh.

His finishing is definitely not elite. Last season under Mancini in a more "reasonable" setup than "all out 4-4-2" he produced 12 goals in 30 games. That's less than Pedro and Alexis Sanchez this season from wide positions playing less minutes. Laughing

For Argentina Higuain is the first choice #9. Compare their minutes throughout the qualifications, Agüero was mostly coming from the bench.

He also doesn't lead the line on his own and always plays alongside another striker to share the workload. Overall he hasn't done anything of note the past 2 seasons. People wank over his potential (which I don't doubt) and because he dribbles. His last big moment was against QPR.

by jibers Thu May 29, 2014 1:03 pm

Fußball wrote:
jibers wrote:
Fußball wrote:They are both overrated as hell.

Elaborate...

Too lazy. But consider this. Agüero is injured more than every 2nd game. Out of the possible 3420 minutes he has played 1526 in the EPL which is less than 50 %. If you also include the minutes where he actually plays but has to find his rythm you've got a full strength Agüero in about about 30 % of the season. He has missed 2 games against Bayern in the CL and had ONE touch against Barcelona in Camp Nou after missing the game in the Etihad. Not reliable.

Consider also this. Despite him missing more than half of the season City have waltzed the league with 100+ goals regardless.

He scores goals in a heavily adventurous side that produces blow-outs every week against teams that City are expected to beat anyway. Any iconic performance against any reasonable side? Meh.

His finishing is definitely not elite. Last season under Mancini in a more "reasonable" setup than "all out 4-4-2" he produced 12 goals in 30 games. That's less than Pedro and Alexis Sanchez this season from wide positions playing less minutes. For Argentina Higuain is the first choice #9. Compare their minutes throughout the qualifications, Agüero was mostly coming from the bench.

He also doesn't lead the line on his own and always plays alongside another striker to share the workload. Overall he hasn't done anything of note the past 2 seasons. People wank over his potential (which I don't doubt) and because he dribbles. His last big moment was against QPR.

okay. fair points. compare him to suarez. who is better for you...

by Robespierre Thu May 29, 2014 1:04 pm

jibers wrote:
Robespierre wrote:Aguero is great but Suarez is definitely better. Suarez is simply Suarez .

Why? Explain. I think Kun is a better finisher

Suarez is more complete than him for me . Suarez is a total player capable to score in every way (became also an excellent free kicker) , it's difficult to find him some weaknesses imo. probably Aguero can be preferred for impact in big games , but for the rest I repeat my preference for El Pistolero who scored 31 goals with no penalties this year, so his finishing is not so bad

by futbol Thu May 29, 2014 3:29 pm

jibers wrote:
Fußball wrote:
jibers wrote:

Elaborate...

Too lazy. But consider this. Agüero is injured more than every 2nd game. Out of the possible 3420 minutes he has played 1526 in the EPL which is less than 50 %. If you also include the minutes where he actually plays but has to find his rythm you've got a full strength Agüero in about about 30 % of the season. He has missed 2 games against Bayern in the CL and had ONE touch against Barcelona in Camp Nou after missing the game in the Etihad. Not reliable.

Consider also this. Despite him missing more than half of the season City have waltzed the league with 100+ goals regardless.

He scores goals in a heavily adventurous side that produces blow-outs every week against teams that City are expected to beat anyway. Any iconic performance against any reasonable side? Meh.

His finishing is definitely not elite. Last season under Mancini in a more "reasonable" setup than "all out 4-4-2" he produced 12 goals in 30 games. That's less than Pedro and Alexis Sanchez this season from wide positions playing less minutes. :lol:For Argentina Higuain is the first choice #9. Compare their minutes throughout the qualifications, Agüero was mostly coming from the bench.

He also doesn't lead the line on his own and always plays alongside another striker to share the workload. Overall he hasn't done anything of note the past 2 seasons. People wank over his potential (which I don't doubt) and because he dribbles. His last big moment was against QPR.

okay. fair points. compare him to suarez. who is better for you...

Suarez is better. Better dribbler. Agüero walzes into traffic like a bull. Suarez is more swiftly, has turns and nutmegs up his sleeve. More variety in the way he takes on defenders. Better creativity. Agüero doesn't involve his teammates. He can lay it off in the box and get some assist numbers but Suarez is a better creator outside of it, can play throughballs etc. Better scorer unless Agüero shows 31 goals without penalties anytime soon. Better freekick taker. More complete player. Go-to guy for his national team, outshining Cavani by far, Copa America winner.

Having said that. Suarez too has to prove himself in bigger stages first. Being a Mule League legend alone doesn't count. :coffee:

by Curtinho Tue Jun 10, 2014 2:17 am

The 2010 WC doesn't count? He was better than Forlan at that tournament despite the latter's award.

by jibers Tue Feb 24, 2015 3:00 am

So where do people stand on this?

by Sponsored content