gotze vs alex oxlade chamberlain

Valid comparison as they both start from wide positions and both drift inside because they've got midfielder attributes. Difference is chamberalain is younger, faster, has a better shot, and has done it againt man utd and manchester city.

everything gotze has achieved can be put down to him being older

Too soon.

everything Gotze has achieved can be put down to him being better.

Or could be that.

Haven't seen Gotze play, but the Ox looks good and a fine acquisition

This is a stupid comparision, Ox has played how many league games in the top division? 3, 4?

Gotze, more than 50.

Well......Cuenca has played about 8 games in the big leauges.......Cllejon has played about 100........dosen't stop Barca fans from saying Cuenca> Callejon.


BTW: I assume you mean who is more talented not who is better.....once it's that I think it's too early to tell exactly how talented Ox is but he seems like a great talent

Goetze is a great talent

THat's the difference.

Well they would be wrong to say that, and to be honest I have barely seen it said so..

Surprised you've been drawn in so deep, Francs. I learned a long time ago not to take comparison threads in the right back section too seriously

Very true, but even this section needs some level of moderating unfortanately.

Probably easier to cut down the b.s as soon as.

The Franchise wrote:everything Gotze has achieved can be put down to him being better.

Or could be that.

Doubt it. Chamberlain looks more talented, and to me its quite clear cut already. Seen a lot of gotze and tried to see it from his fans point of view, but i've never understood the hype. Excellent player? yes, would like him at arsenal. Some kind of super talent? no way imo.

Sure gotze has played a lot more games than aoc, but like you said in a previous argument, it only takes a few games to see how someone plays. And from his performances against the manchester clubs i think its already clear he has more potential than gotze

Gotze, Hazard and Neymar are very very overrated. Lucas, Eriksen, Chamberlain, Draxler and Sarabia are underrated.

They don't play in the same position - you can't compare them, even if we won't consider that Goetze has played much more competitive football.

But I think Capello is thinking to call him up for the Euros.

Gotze is vital member in a championship winning team. Chambo still has his whole career ahead of him.

(I say this but Gotze is pretty young too lol)

Is this a serious thread

Gotze is only 14 months owner and had already won the Golden Boy award for the best young player in Europe.

What has ox done ? Anything ? Ooh he assisted a goal to RvP and automatically became overhyped.

I Have Mono wrote:Is this a serious thread

Gotze is only 14 months owner and had already won the Golden Boy award for the best young player in Europe.

Not interested in what they have done, im interested in how talented they are. Comparing what they have done to decide who is going to be better is ludicrous given the age difference

Before messi even played a senior game i would say messi > gotze and his golden boy award, and chamberlain will be better than gotze, ive got very little doubt about it

I Have Mono wrote:

Ooh he assisted a goal to RvP and automatically became overhyped.

please, gotze is the most overhyped youngster in europe. People got sick of the neymar bandwagon so they needed someone to counter it(gotze)

Next up:

Diego Armando Maradona: "The OX is better than Messi"

english_jewel wrote:Next up:

Diego Armando Maradona: "The OX is better than Messi"

mceachran > messi. Are you happy now?

[quote="Diego Armando Maradona"][quote="english_jewel"]Next up:

Diego Armando Maradona: "The OX is better than Messi"[/quote]

mceachran > messi. Are you happy now? [/quote]

LOL you're the one who goes around comparing The Ox with all the talented youngsters out there for some reason.

LOL maybe you should become a tabloid journalist with your sensationalist trolling. Who i compare him to? gotze and? a throwaway remark about mceachran? not a real comparison ok, didnt know you take any tiny thing to heart

[quote="Diego Armando Maradona"]LOL maybe you should become a tabloid journalist with your sensationalist trolling. Who i compare him to? gotze and? a throwaway remark about mceachran? not a real comparison ok, didnt know you take any tiny thing to heart[/quote]

Trolling? That's what I felt when you came to the Chelsea section and on a particular thread about McEachran started comparing Ox to him even when no one else had brought him up previously

So my first post here was taking a bit of fun at that and what you posted here. No hard feelings.

You got some serious talent at bending the truth. I wasnt even talking about chamberlain on the chelsea section when someone wrote a :lucas: comment at me so i responded with a :lucas: comment, not a serious comparison. The only time i've discussed chamberlain in a serious comparsion is here

It's pretty hard to read things from a smiley, ya know.

:lucas: is not a sign of trolling then?

lol cmon

Goetze is miles better atm, He is up there with hazard, Zaha etc

Oxlade is just getting started