Re: Giorgio Chiellini - Not good

by TrezeGent Fri Jun 15, 2012 1:20 pm

MrDeeds wrote:As their teams would provide anything for Italy smh.

TrezeGent wrote:Not generalizing but looking at Milan and Inter fans bitching and blaming Chiello for Italy's only inability (which is to score) is ridiculous.

As their teams would provide anything for Italy smh.

But, Italy's never been a good scoring team, they were good defending tho :coffee:

[/quote]

Partially true that. But to say Italy are bad at defending today is ridiculous though. I watched the game till the 79th minute, and till that minute, Croatias goal was their only pure slip in defense.

Italy was playing a secure and pretty solid game to a great team until Motta went out, or better said, (mole style) Montoshitto came in. :facepalm:

C'mon, even you know Chiello is one of the worlds best defenders, but if you decide to try and troll my sensitive fellow Juve fans you're not doing that good my fella. :coffee:

by M99 Fri Jun 15, 2012 4:18 pm

I'm with both sides here. Chiellini is a good defender, the goal was totally his fault but everyone makes mistakes, he's nowhere near as bad as some people are making him out to be and he is definitely better than Bonera. Every defender playing professional football is better than Bonera (except against Barca :coffee:

)

But Chiellini>Silva, Chiellini>Stam, what the *bleep* am I reading? To the Juve fan who said that Milanisti would happily exchange Chiellini for Silva, that will happen only if we suffered severe brain damage. And Chiellini will never reach the level of Stam, GTFO. SMH talk about overrating.

by danyjr Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:16 pm

Hint: United's Stam >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> AC Milan's Stam

by guest7 Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:29 pm

I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( Laughing

)

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

by TrezeGent Sat Jun 16, 2012 11:15 am

Se7en wrote:I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( )

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

He has a degree in Economics and Business.

I stopped reading here.

by 7amood11 Sat Jun 16, 2012 12:48 pm

Many of the posts in this thread are just downright ridiculous.

I was shocked when somebody said that Bonucci > Chiellini. My friend, how many Juve games have you watched?

imo Chiellini isn't overrated, but is rated just fine - as a top 5-10 centre-back.

Those who have been saying that he's been committing 2-3 mistakes every game for Juve this season, please show me proof because that's the most ridiculous thing I've read along with "Bonucci > Chiellini".

by C.Marchisio #8 Sat Jun 16, 2012 2:16 pm

What's next ? Mexes > Barzagli ?? Those milan fans :facepalm:

by Forza Sat Jun 16, 2012 2:21 pm

danyjr wrote:Hint: United's Stam >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> AC Milan's Stam

I don't know what this has to do with the topic because I haven't read all of it, but AC Milan Stam was still GOAT... and an absolute psycho-beast-destroyer-box-to-box-sweeper on FIFA back in the day. :coffee:

by danyjr Sat Jun 16, 2012 2:31 pm

[quote="Forza Rossoneri"]

danyjr wrote:I don't know what this has to do with the topic because I haven't read all of it, but AC Milan Stam was still GOAT... and an absolute psycho-beast-destroyer-box-to-box-sweeper on FIFA back in the day.

Hah, you played FIFA back in 2005? Ever heard of PES?

by Forza Sat Jun 16, 2012 2:53 pm

[quote="danyjr"]

Forza Rossoneri wrote:
danyjr wrote:I don't know what this has to do with the topic because I haven't read all of it, but AC Milan Stam was still GOAT... and an absolute psycho-beast-destroyer-box-to-box-sweeper on FIFA back in the day.
Hah, you played FIFA back in 2005? Ever heard of PES?

I've played every FIFA since '05. Brand loyalty :bow:

by nichabr Sat Jun 16, 2012 5:04 pm

TrezeGent wrote:
Se7en wrote:I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( )

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

He has a degree in Economics and Business.

I stopped reading here.

that somehow makes him have a good footballing mind?seriously some people here have got to atleast try to comprehend things a little differently rather than look at the obvious things and base their point on that one little detail.

by Luca Sat Jun 16, 2012 5:06 pm

Milantildeath wrote:He made two crucial mistakes when it mattered in both games, he is a good player......not legendary. I don't think he should be mentioned in the same breath as Maldini, Nesta, Baresi, and Cannavaro

Two? The first game was 100% Giaccherini, he began tracking the run and then stopped lmao

Second game, 100% Chiellini but if you don't think he was monstrous in both games then by all means, continue on

Italy can't defend one goal leads, simple as that

by windkick Sat Jun 16, 2012 6:39 pm

Why is Balloteli starting over DiNatale? Shame

by Dante Sat Jun 16, 2012 6:53 pm

Ganso wrote:
elmystique wrote:is it not amazing that its Milan and Inter fans [well add our own Milan/Inter wolf in sheep skin Juve fan Giacomelajuvesera] who are going on about Chiellini being shat for just one mistake today,

am sure Milan fans would gladly trade TS any day for Chiello, Inter fans I doubt which quality defender you have left to barter.....
Hahhahahanahhahahaaaaaaaaa

i loled with that too , Juventini never stop entertaining me .

by MrDeeds Sat Jun 16, 2012 7:10 pm

TrezeGent wrote:
Se7en wrote:I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( )

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

He has a degree in Economics and Business.

I stopped reading here.

Why, Pepe IS better than Chiellini.

by Dante Sat Jun 16, 2012 7:20 pm

king_alex10 wrote:The most epic lolz was the derossi>>>>>>>>>>>> ... come on now.

Anyway. Anyone who actually understands how Juve's defence worked will see that Barzagli was the one that made the defence successful with his reading of the front line players and his excellent timing. To call chiellini a scrub is silly, but hes not exactly the best either. Its ok to admit it, he has been mistake prone in the past and wasnt Juventus best defender. In the line up we have right now, hes probably the best df Italy have.

Hes good, but he isnt the GOAT... I can actually see Bonucci ending up better overall than him in the future

Perhaps King's post is the only legit post by a Juventino in this thread .

With no bias or over rating or half truths about Chiellini. Congrats King . Maybe explain this to the guy who said Milan fans would happily swap Silva with Chiellini.

Chiellini isn't that shit as some make him out to be , but lol that a Milanista would swap Silva for him . There's more chance to see Pescara win Serie A next season .

by Babun Sat Jun 16, 2012 7:46 pm

He isn't bad or anything. He is very good but not elite because in each game he does something braindead once.

by guest7 Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:14 pm

TrezeGent wrote:
Se7en wrote:I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( )

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

He has a degree in Economics and Business.

I stopped reading here.

Indeed. Here is him using that degree in Economics and Business to full effect:

Giorgio Chiellini - Not good - Page 4 Nosonja

The guy is as much of a thug as Pepe and both have the same weaknesses. Both cover it up by being physical beasts.

So overrated here. Pepe > Chiellini.

by Luca Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:46 pm

Pepe>Chiellini

Lmao

by Cookie Monster Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:48 pm

TrezeGent wrote:
Se7en wrote:I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( )

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

He has a degree in Economics and Business.

I stopped reading here.

Since when does having a degree make someone intelligent? Do you know how many dumb-asses skim by University with D's and end up with degrees? Also, how does a degree in business relate to footballing smarts?

by Cookie Monster Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:48 pm

Luca wrote:Pepe>Chiellini

Lmao

Yeah that's a little excessive lol

by danyjr Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:51 pm

Please stop comparing Chiellini, a human to the animal Pepe is.

by Luca Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:53 pm

Cookie Monster wrote:
TrezeGent wrote:
Se7en wrote:I've said this before.

He is incredibly overrated in my opinion, he is a thug, very clumsy and lacks a brain. (or just doesnt have a good one overall)

I really think he is at the same level of Pepe, not really higher. Both are similair in the way that they're physical beasts rather than tactical defenders. And Chielleni is no way near the level of Thiago Silva ( )

He is a good player, but he is very overrated aswell.

He has a degree in Economics and Business.

I stopped reading here.

Since when does having a degree make someone intelligent? Do you know how many dumb-asses skim by University with D's and end up with degrees? Also, how does a degree in business relate to footballing smarts?

He completed his PhD in economics
Dr. Giorgio

And that's not really any sort of point to make, but being a professional footballer for a massive club which pays you millions and still continuing with your education makes you a very smart person.

Cookie Monster wrote:
Luca wrote:Pepe>Chiellini

Lmao

Yeah that's a little excessive lol

Beyond excessive

Chiellini is not a thug, he is a physical player but not a thug by any means
Awful comparison
When has Chiellini intentionally tried to hurt a player? When has he received a red card for a moment of absolute madness? When has he stomped on an opposing player? When has he taken a kick at his own player?

Never.

Chiellini is a world class defender.
Italy is not good enough to defend a one goal lead, that's really what the first two games has showed us more than anything. Chiellini massively *bleep* up for that Croatia goal, but lets be real, Italy didn't even show up for the second half.

by guest7 Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:54 pm

danyjr wrote:Please stop comparing Chiellini, a human to the animal Pepe is.

Maybe you should watch Juve more often... Chiellini does the same things as Pepe does. Wish CroInter was here so he could post all the gifs of him commiting thuggery

by Luca Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:55 pm

Se7en wrote:
danyjr wrote:Please stop comparing Chiellini, a human to the animal Pepe is.

Maybe you should watch Juve more often... Chiellini does the same things as Pepe does. Wish CroInter was here so he could post all the gifs of him commiting thuggery

Maybe you should watch Juventus more often, he doesn't even come remotely close to Pepe.

And, he is a much better player overall

by guest7 Sat Jun 16, 2012 10:03 pm

I just posted a gif of him PUNCHING Boatang Laughing

Like I said before, I wish CroInter was here so he could post his millions of gifs where Chiellini just does something stupid (thuggery)

by Sponsored content